Papa Joe`s Pizza in Quarryville

Good food,great service.

I really liked the food, the only thing is I ordered half pepperoni and half cheese, over half the pizza was pepperoni. It wasn't a big problem though.

If I could give them 10 stars I would. Ever since the reopening after the fire, this is our go-to place for takeout. Staff is always friendly and accommodating. The food is amazing. We order something different every time and it’s alwags fantastic. Get the smoked wings! You won’t regret it!

Not from the area, but stopped for a bite and must say it was fantastic The food was outstanding, the staff was friendly, and the place was clean The Mac and cheese with bbq brisket was really tastyWe also had a grinder,pizza,Brisket meal and they have orange Fanta in the bottle!!Thanks

Horrible place to get food from. Lots of problems with not getting what you order. That could be because the owners small children are working in the back. Asked to have out subs cut on one side, and they wont do it even though they do cheese steaks the same way. This will be the last time we eat out from there. Get your food from roses.

Delicious food with a lot of in house made ingredients. Best home made Italian spicy sausage I ever had. Stromboli are so good here. Best I've ever had. Will drive out of my way to eat here. Highly recommended.

Good food, decent timing for the food - except for one time waiting 30 min for salad and wings. Dislike not having fountain sodas. The bottles of soda do not last for a meal.

Rolls are good, but putting less in them than they used to

Excellent food! Quality, fresh ingredients every time. Clean, welcoming, establishment. Their customer service is what really sets them apart from others though! You can definitely tell that this business is run with integrity! It’s my new “go to” pizza shop.

This pizza is good,it's fast food and it's always hot!

We stopped in for takeout and no employees were wearing face masks except one person in the back. We asked the employee who was preparing our food to put on a face mask and she did, but she immediately took it off afterwards. Face masks are mandatory in public places right now in Pennsylvania given the governor's most recent regulation in response to COVID-19. In the food service environment, food and health safety is of utmost importance and we will not return to Papa's Joe's until they respect the rules.

Fantastic service and delicious food. My salad was just right and the wings were superb. I ordered for carry out and my food was packaged well and ready when they said it would be.

Food was good but none of the employees were wearing masks

Great food and wonderful friendly customer service ! We love it here.

Overall, loved the pizza. Good selection of beverages. Appealing rustic decorations. You feel at home with the welcoming staff.

I have to say it is a very sad day.. After Five years of eating at Papa Joe's in Quarryvile two owners a fire and spending thousands of dollars there eating. I or the team will not be stopping here anymore. After ordering $20 of hot wings and $20 in pizza, they come out with no blue cheese . I send Hunter back to the counter to get some and he comes back with one little container. I said this cannot be right . I go back to the counter to ask for another when I am told that they charge for blue cheese the first one was complimentary and I would have to pay for the other. Again i just paid $20 for 24 wings which is fine but at no time was I asked if I wanted blue cheese/ ranch how many and it would be extra. So after a rude comment about having to pay for another one I have decided to not do business here anymore. Hope you are happy with the .50 worth of blue cheese you shorted me out of ... The tip was given prior to the whole blue cheese episode.. Sad Sad day..

The service was good, they were busy and they put plenty of topping on. I just wish they made their own crust. The crust was disappointing.

Good food and nice place to eat outside if weather is fitting.

This pizza spot is definitely a family run place based on the workers, and it lives up to the expectations. A friend and I stopped by for a few slices and were very happy with the service. The cashier was polite, and the pizza slices they gave us were HUGE! The inside was decorated nicely, and everything was very clean and neat including the restroom I used. I would definitely go again.

Massive subs/hoagies bbq sauce slamming

The best pizza I've ever had

We walked in to order take-out and no employees were wearing masks except for one. The girl at the register began to make our sub and we asked her to please put on a mask while preparing our food. She did, and proceeded to immediately take it off once she was done. We were under the impression that masks are required in PA and we will not be returning until Papa Joe’s enforces that. Of all areas to respect the safety rules, food prep is of utmost importance.

I had a tuna salad and a drink. Good food, very reasonable price ! Nothing fancy, but a nice place to eat !

The bacon on the cheeseburger sub is to die for

Much better now that they rebuilt

Our first time there. Actually just stopped in to use the facilities. Saw that it wasn't too crowded. Midday on a Sunday. Clean establishment, friendly, courteous staff. Good prices. We only had a personal size pizza (w/broccoli & feta) on this trip. Crust just right. Sauce very good. Not too salty. Toppings fresh. We'll be back.

Great All American cheeseburger and fries on our first visit. Second visit a week later they were still out of sub rolls. Got the mushroom and onion burger....it was okay, didn’t taste like fresh ground beef and was quite salty.

Friendly, prompt service. Good food. Reasonable prices.

Place looks nice, but the old Papa Joe’s food was much better. I don’t know why they have to try to get fancy and try to change everything.

Its all about the cheese steak

All the food was delicious. The fried mushrooms had great flavor, the smoky wings were flavorful, and the Chicago-style stuffed pizza was just amazing!

My husband's sandwich was great. My fried chicken sandwich was so fried that it was shoe leather. I can chalk that up to a new staff. However, its an open kitchen so we could literally hear the teen staff talking, loudly, about their weekends AND not knowing how to make my sandwich. That should have been my sign.

Great pizza crust!!New England style. Pizza was good, but didnt care for the sliced sausage though.Great service!!

Great food!!. Was a wee bit chilly and stereo a wee bit loud.Bathrooms clean. Again....Great Food!!!

Amazing food. Great place. Great employees.

Probably the most disappointing chicken cheesesteak I’ve had in quite some time.

My husband and I started coming here to eat back in 1989. Our favorite date place. And now it's our kids favorite place to eat. Always friendly faces and excellent service. Scrumptious food!

Not bad. Give it a shot

Good food. Wings nice and crispy

Been going here for the past 40 years. Even though it's under new management. Still a great small place with excellent service and great food.

Good pizza, fast service. Will go back again.

Excellent service & food keep doing wht ur doing! The rustic design was welcoming as well as the Edison lighting design!

The worst pizza I've ever had, just left there overcooked to the point, no sauce.

First time here in a few years; just stopped to buy a pizza to go. Best cheese steak pizza around. Very good. Nice changes to the establishment. Friendly, accommodating staff.

Cheesy fries were great. Pizza was OK.

We had a nice lunch they are we enjoyed Swiss mushroom burger and my hubby had a chicken Caesar wrap what you really enjoy they have really great coleslaw and comfortable atmosphere

Pizza

I have to say it is a very sad day.. After Five years of eating at Papa Joe's in Quarryvile two owners a fire and spending thousands of dollars there eating. I or the team will not be stopping here anymore. After ordering $20 of hot wings and pizza, they come out with no blue cheese . I send Hunter back to the counter to get some and he comes back with one little container. I said this cannot be right . I go back to the counter to ask for another when I am told that they charge for blue cheese the first one was complimentary and I would have to pay for the other. Again i just paid $20 for 24 wings which is fine but at no time was I asked if I wanted blue cheese/ ranch how many and it would be extra. So after a rude comment about having to pay for another one I have decided to not do business here anymore. Hope you are happy with the .50 worth of blue cheese you shorted me out of ... The tip was given prior to the whole blue cheese episode.. Sad Sad day..

Ordered "the works." It was the best pizza we've ever eaten. Fresh and delicious ingredients and a perfect crust!

Pizza is yummy! I've only had the veg. Would love to try others. Dining area is dark and lacks atmosphere. Best to call order in and take out